傾斜する土間
軽井沢にある篠原一男のTanikawa Houseでのお茶会に参加した後、軽井沢千住博美術館に行った。
くしくも、両建築とも、時代は違うが、斜面地をそのまま利用した傾斜する土間を持つという共通点がある。だが、受ける印象は全く違う。
Tanikawa Houseは、斜面という地形を建築という形式に取り込み、跡形もなく建築化している。だから、建物周りの斜面と連続してはいるものの、土間に立った時に地形を感じることは無い。
軽井沢千住博美術館は、地形そのものを空間化しているようで、ガラスや屋根といった内と外を区切る輪郭があるから辛うじて建築だとわかるような、土間に立つと、土間=地形だと感じる。
Tanikawa Houseは、建築の形式の強度が強く、建築の姿や佇まいが自然と相対している。
軽井沢千住博美術館は、地形を空間化し、建築は輪郭だけ、建築の形式の強度は弱く、建築の姿や佇まいが無く、建築と自然が同化しているが、それを形式と考え、自然と同化できる位に強い形式を有しているとも言えなくもないが、Tanikawa Houseが持つ強い建築形式とは全く真逆の形式なので、両建築を比較した場合は、軽井沢千住博美術館の建築形式の強度は弱いとなるだろう。
どちらも世界的な建築で、感動してしまう位に素晴らしい建築体験をもたらしてくれるが、個人的には何故だか、建築形式の強度が強く、建築の姿や佇まいがはっきりと現れているものに惹かれてしまう。
"Inclined soil"
After attending a tea party at Tanikawa House by Shinohara Kazuo in Karuizawa, I went to the Karuizawa Senju Museum.
In addition, both architectures have a common point that they have sloping soils that use sloped land as they are, although the times are different. However, the impression I receive is completely different.
Tanikawa House incorporates the terrain of slopes into the form of architecture, and is built without a trace. Therefore, although it is continuous with the slopes around the building, it does not feel the terrain when standing in the dirt.
The Karuizawa Senju Museum of Art seems to make the terrain itself spatial, and because it has a contour that separates the inside and the outside, such as glass and roof, when you stand in the dirt, you can feel that it is a terrain = terrain.
Tanikawa House is strong in the form of architecture, and the appearance and appearance of architecture are relative to nature.
The Karuizawa Senju Museum of Art has spatialized the terrain, the architecture is only outline, the strength of the architectural form is weak, there is no form or appearance of the architecture, the architecture and nature are assimilated, but it is considered as a form, Although it can be said that it has a strong form that can be assimilated, it is completely opposite to the strong architectural form that Tanikawa House has, so when comparing the two architectures, the architectural form of Karuizawa Senju Museum of Art The strength will be weak.
Both are world-class architectures that bring amazing architectural experiences to the touch, but for personal reasons, the strength of the architectural style is strong and the appearance and appearance of the architecture is clearly visible I will be attracted.